All news
Helix
Helix
··7 min read

One-Third of Consumers Now Ask AI Where to Buy — Bain Says Market Share No Longer Guarantees Visibility

Bain's latest research finds 33% of US and 36% of European consumers use AI assistants while shopping, with AI referral traffic converting 90% better — and category specialists are beating market-share leaders in AI answers.

One-Third of Consumers Now Ask AI Where to Buy — Bain Says Market Share No Longer Guarantees Visibility

Bain & Company published a landmark report today analysing more than 4,400 shopping prompts across 300,000 unique runs on the most-used large language models — and the headline finding should concern every business that sells anything: one-third of consumers now use AI assistants during their shopping journey, and the businesses that show up in AI answers are not necessarily the ones with the biggest market share.

The new search funnel is a conversation

The shift is unmistakable. Bain's Consumer Lab global survey found that 33% of US consumers and 36% of European consumers now say they use AI assistants for some part of the shopping journey as of November 2026 — up from 19% and 8% in September 2025. ChatGPT alone serves 1.2 billion weekly users, with an estimated 15% to 20% of prompts being shopping-related — roughly 1.7 billion retail and ecommerce prompts per week, according to OpenAI's own figures.

And these shoppers aren't just asking "where can I buy AA batteries?" They're asking AI to plan entire occasions: "Help me host a holiday dinner for eight." The AI recommends a short list of retailers — far shorter than Google's pages of blue links. If you're not on that list, you don't exist.

Yes, AI assistants still account for less than 1% of direct referral traffic to retailers. But Bain's analysis, drawing on Similarweb data, found that AI referral traffic converts 90% better than non-AI traffic. And click-through rates drastically undercount the real influence — many shoppers use AI to research and compare, then visit retailers directly.

Specialists are beating the giants

Here's where it gets interesting for smaller businesses. Bain's analysis, powered by Profound data, tested which retailers appear in AI answers across four retail verticals. The finding: category specialists consistently over-index in AI answers relative to their market share.

"AI assistants are rewarding the retailers that are clearest about who they serve and what they do best, because shoppers ask specific questions and specific answers win," said Aaron Cheris, global head of Bain's Retail practice.

In grocery, for instance, Kroger appeared more often for prompts about promotion and loyalty, while Whole Foods outperformed on dietary needs and product selection. The AI doesn't default to the biggest player — it defaults to the most relevant one for the specific question being asked.

This inverts decades of marketing logic. Scale and brand recognition have always bought visibility. In AI answers, a clear, well-communicated value proposition matters more than shelf space.

The three-front war for AI visibility

Bain identifies three battlegrounds every business now faces: third-party assistants (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini), first-party assistants (the retailer's own AI), and personal agents like Meta's Muse.

On third-party assistants, the game is Generative Engine Optimisation (GEO) — shaping what AI models know, trust, and say about your products. The citations LLMs draw on are highly fragmented, but earned media currently leads for most models. Critically, that mix keeps shifting: a recent ChatGPT update, for example, sharply cut social media citations in favour of retailer websites and earned media.

Bain's practical advice: spell out who you're best for, what exclusive products you have, and which occasions you serve. Build structured, readable, accurate site content. And never stop testing, because AI answers shift for reasons both inside and outside your control.

On the first-party front, only 27 of the top 100 US retailers have their own AI assistant — yet consumers trust retailer-built AI assistants nearly twice as much as third-party ones (21% vs 12%). The results are hard to ignore: Walmart says Sparky users spend 40% more per order, and Amazon reports Alexa for Shopping users spend 50% more, with over 400 million customers using it in the past year and interactions up 570% year over year. (Worth noting: neither company has disclosed holdout testing, so these are correlations between self-selected users, not proven causal effects.)

Australian retailers are moving fast

This isn't a US-only story. Australian retailers are among the most aggressive movers in agentic commerce. Bunnings launched Buddy, a Gemini-powered shopping assistant that managing director Michael Schneider says has more than doubled online conversion rates and increased basket sizes through project-based shopping. Bunnings is also set to be one of the first Australian retailers to sell through Google AI Mode.

Woolworths is upgrading its Olive chatbot into an agentic loyalty assistant powered by Google's Gemini Enterprise for CX, with capabilities including meal planning, cart building, and personalised recommendations. And Wesfarmers has partnered with Google Cloud to roll agentic shopping across Kmart, Officeworks, Priceline, and OnePass.

For smaller Australian businesses without the resources to build their own AI assistant, the third-party visibility game is where to start. OpenAI's Business Hub, launched just ten days ago, lets businesses claim their ChatGPT profile and launch a free Business Agent — a concrete first step toward showing up in the AI shopping conversation.

What to watch

The personal agent wave is the wildcard. Meta's Muse reached more than 10 million users in the US and Canada within six weeks of launch, with shopping as the number one use case and average purchases exceeding $200. Mark Zuckerberg told analysts he expects Muse to eventually generate more revenue per user than Facebook and Instagram combined.

Bain forecasts the US agentic commerce market could reach $300 to $500 billion by 2030, representing 15% to 25% of overall ecommerce. That's not a distant future — it's four years away.

The businesses that will thrive in this shift are the ones that treat AI visibility with the same discipline they brought to SEO a decade ago. The good news from Bain's data is clear: you don't need to be the biggest. You need to be the most specific about what you do and who you serve. For a category specialist or a focused small business, that's not a disadvantage — it's the entire point.


Sources

I'm here to help — ready when you are.